Sam Elliott Criticizes Contemporary Western Film, Supports American Cowboy Heritage

Sam Elliott, a veteran actor renowned for his roles in western films, recently made headlines for his candid critique of the movie “The Power of the Dog” and its director, Jane Campion. In an interview on Marc Maron’s “WTF Podcast,” Elliott expressed strong opinions about the film’s portrayal of cowboy culture and the American West, sparking a debate about the representation of these themes in modern cinema.

Actor Sam Elliott in the tv series 1883 (Credit: YouTube)

Elliott’s comments were direct and unfiltered, reflecting his deep connection to the cowboy persona he has often portrayed on screen. He criticized the film for its portrayal of cowboys, comparing them to Chippendales dancers and expressing dismay at what he perceived as heavy-handed allusions to homosexuality. Elliott also questioned Campion’s qualifications to depict the American West, noting her New Zealand background and her decision to film the movie in her home country, which was meant to represent Montana.

“I love her previous work, but what the f—k does this woman from down there, New Zealand, know about the American West?” Elliott exclaimed during the podcast. He further criticized Campion’s choice to film in New Zealand, stating, “Why in the f—k does she shoot this movie in New Zealand and call it Montana and say, ‘This is the way it was’? That rubbed me the wrong way, pal.”

Benedict Cumberbatch in The Power of the Dog (Credit: YouTube)

Elliott’s critique extended to the film’s main character, played by Benedict Cumberbatch, whom he felt did not embody the true spirit of the American cowboy. He argued that the character’s portrayal lacked authenticity and failed to capture the essence of cowboy culture, particularly its emphasis on family values and community.

Despite the backlash from some quarters, Elliott’s comments struck a chord with many who share his passion for preserving the legacy of the American cowboy. His remarks reflect a broader sentiment among some Americans who feel that Hollywood has drifted away from traditional values and has failed to accurately depict historical and cultural narratives.

Sam Elliott in 1883 (Credit: YouTube)

The controversy surrounding Elliott’s remarks highlights the ongoing debate over the portrayal of cowboy culture in film and the role of filmmakers in depicting these themes authentically. While some view Elliott’s comments as outdated or insensitive, others see them as a valid critique of a film that may have taken liberties with its portrayal of historical events and cultural nuances.

In conclusion, Sam Elliott’s critique of “The Power of the Dog” has reignited discussions about the representation of cowboy culture in modern cinema. Whether one agrees or disagrees with his views, Elliott’s passionate defense of cowboy culture underscores the importance of preserving and honoring the rich history and traditions of the American West.

Related Posts

Melania Trump’s wedding dress ‘for sale’ on eBay for eye-watering amount

Melania’s opulent Christian Dior dress, designed by John Galliano, from her January 2005 wedding to Donald Trump was listed for sale at $45,000 (or best offer)—a steep…

I ASKED MY NEIGHBOR TO CLEAN UP AFTER USING MY BBQ — THE NEXT DAY, SHE LEFT HER OWN “RULES” ON MY DOOR, BUT I SHUT THAT DOWN. So, about six months ago, a new neighbor moved in — a woman (40) with her son (16). At first, she seemed chill. I even lent her some household stuff and let her use my outdoor grill station when we weren’t home. No big deal, right? Wrong. One weekend, me, my husband and our kids went to visit my parents. We came back, and boom — MY BACKYARD LOOKED LIKE A FRAT HOUSE HAD JUST HOSTED A BBQ APOCALYPSE. Empty bottles, food scraps, grill left dirty like it had survived a grease explosion. I ask her about it, and she just shrugs, saying it was her son’s birthday, so you know, it’s just kids, it’s what kids do. Apparently, I shouldn’t make a fuss over something so minor. Lady, it’s my backyard, not a public park! So, I do the reasonable thing. I draft up three simple rules: 1. If you use something, clean it and put it back. 2. Please, clean up after your child. 3. That’s it. Just be respectful. I hand it to her, thinking we’re all good. THE NEXT DAY, I WAKE UP TO A LIST OF HER RULES TAPED TO MY DOOR. HER rules. For MY property. Spoiler: I didn’t follow her rules. In two weeks, her son knocked on my door and pleaded, “Ma’am, please, stop!” 👇🏼 Full story in the first comment 👇

Camilla allows her new neighbor, Claire, to use her barbecue… until she goes home to a backyard disaster. When Camilla asks for basic respect, her neighbor demands…

MY SISTER TOOK BACK THE CAR SHE GIFTED ME AFTER I UPGRADED IT, SO I TAUGHT HER A LESSON. My older sister sold me her old car for a symbolic amount. It hadn’t run in ages, with flat tires and rust under the hood. But she made a big deal out of gifting it to me. Knowing my way around cars, I invested $5,000 to upgrade everything—new interior, fresh paint, new tires, and wheels. I was thrilled with the result. One morning, as I was about to leave for university, my sister stormed in, DEMANDING THE CAR BACK. I was sh0cked. She claimed her husband’s car had broken down, and since she hadn’t sent the sale documents, the car was still legally hers. She said she had changed her mind. My parents sided with her, arguing that she needed the car for her kids. My first thought was to call the police, but then I had a better idea. I decided to teach her a lesson she wouldn’t forget. I went to ⬇️ Full story in 1st comment

To be honest, I never imagined a beat-up old automobile would become the center of family drama, but here we are. It all began when my older…

A POOR BOY’S LIFE CHANGES AFTER HE PULLS AN OLD, RUSTY CHAIN STICKING OUT OF THE SAND ON A REMOTE BEACH Adam is 13 years old and lives with his grandfather in an old trailer near the ocean. His parents passed away when he was just 3, and since then, his grandpa has been his only family. They don’t have much, but his grandpa has raised him well—Adam is strong, smart, and way more mature than most kids his age. One afternoon, he rode his bike down to the beach, just like any other day. He wandered along the shore, letting the waves tickle his feet—until something caught his eye. A thick, rusted chain lay partially buried in the sand. Curious, Adam grabbed it and pulled—but it barely budged. Whatever it was connected to was massive. From that moment on, Adam became obsessed with digging. He had no idea what he was about to uncover—or how it was about to change his life forever ⬇️

The rusted chain jutting from the sand seemed worthless to everyone else, but to 13-year-old Adam, it promised an escape from poverty. He couldn’t have known that…

THEY WERE PRAYING IN A CIRCLE—BUT NO ONE TAUGHT THEM HOW It was just after snack time, and I was washing out some paint cups when I noticed the room had gone oddly quiet. Too quiet for a group of 4- and 5-year-olds who usually treated volume like a sport. I turned the corner into the play area and stopped in my tracks. Four of them—Niko, Janelle, Izzy, and Samir—were sitting cross-legged in a perfect little circle. Hands held. Eyes shut. Heads bowed. They were whispering something I couldn’t quite catch at first. I thought maybe it was a song or one of those rhyming games they loved. But when I leaned in, I realized they were… praying. Like, really praying. Asking for things. Saying “Amen.” Janelle even crossed herself at the end like she’d seen in church. Thing is, we don’t do any kind of religious activity in our classroom. It’s a public kindergarten. No nativity plays, no Bible stories, nothing. And I’d never seen any of these four talk about faith or even mimic that kind of behavior before. I crouched down and gently asked, “Hey, what are you guys doing?” Izzy opened one eye and whispered, “We’re asking the sky to help us.” “Help you with what?” I asked. Niko just said, ⬇️

It was just after snack time, and I was washing out some paint cups when I noticed the room had gone oddly quiet. Too quiet for a…

Try stretching your ring finger with your thumb and holding it for a few seconds. You’ll be amazed by the reason behind it! (check in first comment👇)

Can we achieve peace and harmony with just our hands? Let’s explore some mudras (hand gestures) and their benefits: Gyan Mudra (Knowledge Mudra): How to do it: Sit…